These hours reflect the most recent public data we have. For the most current schedule, call or visit the business.
Gage & Tollner Photos
Most recent photos pulled from the Google Business Profile for this report.
About Gage & Tollner
Gage & Tollner, a historic local eatery nestled on Fulton Street in Brooklyn, offers a refined yet nostalgic dining experience anchored by its retro aesthetic and timeless menu. We observed that patrons consistently praise the venue for its expertly shucked oysters, robust cuts of steak and chop, and a curated selection of wines and cocktails that complement the hearty fare. The ambiance strikes a balance between old-world charm and modern comfort, making it a go-to for both celebratory dinners and casual indulgences. Customers describe the service as attentive without being intrusive, and the kitchen’s consistency is frequently noted in reviews. This venue thrives on its reputation for quality ingredients and classic preparation, appealing to those who value tradition with a touch of flair. Whether you’re seeking a romantic night out or a memorable meal with friends, this establishment suits diners who appreciate atmosphere as much as flavor — especially those drawn to Brooklyn’s storied culinary heritage.
The 20 closest same-category competitors within 5 miles of Gage & Tollner, grouped by direction. Cards highlight the four most strategically important directions.
Same-category businesses in Plus Code area 87G8M2 (covering Brooklyn · Brooklyn Heights · New York) — a 5.5 km × 5.5 km neighborhood. Ranked #1 → #9 by rating and review volume.
The #1 competitor in this grid has 1.3× the reach of Gage & Tollner.
Services Offered
Services Gage & Tollner lists on its Google Business Profile — the exact terms customers search, and the signals that power service-level visibility.
She-Crab SoupBlue Crab, Sherry$21.00Mushroom SoupRas el Hanout, Porcini Butter$16.00G&T CaesarRomaine, Parmigiano-Reggiano, Croutons$15.00Winter SaladMixed GreensHerbs, Aged Sherry Wine Vinaigrette, Shallots$13.00Roasted BeetsWhipped Ricotta, Pistachio Purée, SabaWedge Salad$18.00Chèvre CheesecakeSatsuma, Meyer Lemon, Bergamot, Hazelnut$14.00Chocolate Peanut Butter PuddingPeanut Crumble, Molasses CreamCoconut Layer CakeLime Curd, Cashew-Pink Peppercorn Brittle, KumkuatMalted Milk and Dark Chocolate TorteEspresso Crème Anglaise and Salted CaramelPear & Spiced Fig Sundae$17.00Baked Alaska for Two$26.00Scoops$6.00Selection of Four CheesesCreamed SpinachKale & Kimchi Slaw$10.00Sautéed Seasonal MushroomsRoasted Root Vegetables with Bagna CaudaBrussels SproutsBuckwheat Honey, Fish Sauce, Aji Dulce
Competitor Comparison
How Gage & Tollner stacks up against same-category american restaurant within ~15 miles, by Google review volume. Bar length = review count; rating shown at right.
Junior's Restaurant & Bake…
15,586 rev · 4.4★
Nathan's Famous
15,490 rev · 4.3★
Junior's Restaurant and Ba…
12,990 rev · 4.4★
Junior's Restaurant & Bake…
12,987 rev · 4.4★
Vistamar Restaurant & Loun…
11,616 rev · 4.8★
Bubby's
8,688 rev · 4.4★
Mojo
6,625 rev · 4.7★
Serendipity 3 - Upper East…
6,591 rev · 4.1★
Gage & Tollner ranks #9 of 9 nearby american restaurant by review volume, with a lower rating than the local average of 4.4★ (its own rating: 4.3★). The main gap is review count, not review quality — growing review velocity is the clearest lever to become more competitive locally.
Also frequently compared — via Google
Businesses Google associates with this one in “people also search for” — brand and category rivals beyond the nearby ring.
Henry's EndLibertadorFat FowlBotte Brooklyn
Demographics of your service area
US Census Bureau, ACS 5-year · ZCTA 11201
Total population
69,755
Median household income
$163,310
Households with kids
20.7%
Bachelor's or higher
78.1%
What Customers Talk About
Drawn from Gage & Tollner’s Google reviews — the exact language customers use, which is gold for matching real search intent.
Services customers mention
Wedge Salad — in 1 review
Online Visibility Scorecard
Six dimensions of how Gage & Tollner shows up — and converts — in local search, scored from public Google Business Profile signals and the website. This is a listing-quality measure — not a live local-pack ranking; a full 49-cell GeoGrid rank scan is available on request.
84
Overall visibility score
out of 100
Grade A-
Profile Completeness
How fully the public Google Business Profile is filled out.
Strong
Reputation
Star rating and review volume — the strongest first impression in search.
Strong
Freshness
Recent activity signals — posts, photos, and up-to-date hours.
Observations from your public ranking signals — every line is derived from data already on your Google Business Profile or in the public local pack.
✓
Google Business Profile is 91% complete
Profile signals are competitive with top-3 local-pack winners. Ranking gap (if any) is now driven by review velocity + active engagement, not profile fields.
★
4.3★ rating (1,359 reviews)
Near category median. Top-3 local-pack winners typically sit 4.5★+. Every fresh 5-star review compounds; every fresh 1-star nullifies several.
⌖
Target keyword: "american restaurant near me"
This is the highest-intent local search for American restaurant in Brooklyn, NY. Local-pack ranking for this term is the single largest lever on monthly inbound volume.
How Stormrage Helps American restaurant Operators in Brooklyn
Local american restaurant marketing is a rank-by-data game. The 4.3★ rating from 1,359 reviews puts Gage & Tollner near the category median — the three moves with measurable lift are: claim and complete the Google Business Profile, build NAP-consistent citations toward top-3 local-pack parity, and grow monthly review velocity. Each one compounds on the previous; skipping one wastes the others.
Stormrage runs all three as a single workstream and tracks rank-position movement weekly with transparent case-study reporting. If Gage & Tollner would rather book the calls than do the homework, that’s exactly what we do — the contact form below connects directly to a strategist within 24 hours.
Ready to Dominate Local Search?
These gaps compound — claim, website, photos, and review velocity each lift the others, and skipping one wastes the rest. Stormrage runs the full sequence for american restaurant operators in Brooklyn, NY and reports the rank-position lift weekly. Reach us at stormrage.nyc or (646) 450-7178.
Follow Gage & Tollner on Social